Talk:Prabhat Samgiita

From Sarkarverse
Jump to: navigation, search

A few points for consideration

A few points for consideration:

  1. Will the use of small caps for the first item under Sources (and "Online sources") be a regular feature? I have no objection if this is so. I merely prefer consistency.
  2. Again, under Sources, is there any good reason why we are presenting the name of Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar with a Roman-script spelling that he did not use (and that is inconsistent with the preferred spelling on Sarkarverse)? Note that nowhere else on Sarkarverse do we use or encourage "Shrii Prabhát Raiṋjan Sarkár" (with the honorific, the uccis, and a nicci). I think that the name should be written simply as "Sarkar, Prabhat Ranjan" (without the honorific 'Shrii' and with a single link, not a double link as currently found). I also would strongly discourage such type of needlessly confusing pedantry. Already, this article dwells at length and very early on such type of subject matter, which is at best peripheral to the main topic, that is, the music and lyrics of Prabhat Samgiita.
  3. Under "External links", can anyone confirm that prabhatasamgiita.net is in fact an "official" website for Prabhat Samgiita. I have no information that this is so. If no one can confirm such information, then that site should be referenced without declaring it as "official".
  4. This article greatly requires both an infobox and an SVmap_NonliteraryWorks.png. The infobox should _not_ present Prabhat Samgiita as "Indian music" but rather as universal music, because much of Prabhat Samgiita is a blending of both Eastern and Western styles.

--Abhidevananda (talk) 10:43, 5 November 2013 (MST)

Few more points
  • Use Sfn or Harvnb sources or just plain cite web/news/book.
  • Do not use bold formatting unnecessarily. TitoDutta 11:12, 5 November 2013 (MST)

Reference section

Reference section requires cleanup. some references are broken. TitoDutta 06:16, 21 May 2014 (MDT)